Opportunities in Earth Observation Satellite Services:
Opportunities in Earth Observation Satellite Services:
Lessons of the Past for the Future
Lessons of the Past for the Futur
Industry Symposium
49th Scientific & Technical Subcommittee COPUOS
OSSA,Vienna, February 13, 2012
The value chain in commercial satellite Earth observation
The space industry: 30 companies competing worldwide on
accessible markets. EOsat increasingly capable thanks to technology
effort at bus and instrument levels
Satellite operators procure satellites (and launches) to produce
optical and radar imagery available for sale: < 10 companies
market principally HR EO data directly to end-users and/or
through resellers
Over 300 service providers of different capabilities add
value to the data incorporated in sector-specific geospatial
information systems (maritime, geodesy, agriculture, ..).
Industry fragmented by geography and specialty
< 10 companies worldwide manufacture ground equipment
for data reception and pre-processing
Satellite & Launch *
Terminal
manufacturers
1.3
1.9
0.5
0.5
Commercial EO
satellite operators
Value added
service
providers
EO is commercial mostly for data sales driven by governement needs (defense & security) for HR
imagery. Upstream & downstream also dominated by government demand
Service market at 1.5 time the data market (x 7.5 in comsat but not the same economic logic)
*excluding government-funded satellites
Satellite role for geo-information based decision-making
Defense &
Security
Environment
monitoring
Energy
Natural
resources
monitoring
Maritime
Disaster
management
Location-
based
services
Optical
data
needs
HR data
Instruments diversity
for atmospheric
study, land-sea
interact, ozone…
HR (infrastructure,
logistics) & MR
(geological maps)
MR (20-30m) in IR
for wide agriculture;
HR in precision agri.
& forest
MR/LR for
algae.
Fisheries &
costal zones
HR for logistics
and crisis
mapping
HR high
accuracy
Radar
data
needs
HR data with
night imaging
and no cloud
Ocean currents
model, tidal info from
MR
HR/MR (offshore
seepage) + optical
for geology maps.
InSAR for
subsidence
Surface
texture/water
content for land
(geology,
agriculture)
HR/MR for sea
ice. HR for ship
track, transport
HR in flood
mapping
Few
needs
Revisit
needs
Max. for 1m is 1
day
Depend on scope of
the study, incl. real
time meteo, archive &
continuity
Recent & NRT.
Archive good for
geological map
Low for monitoring
(agriculture, forest)
Low for ship
track
HR for
responsiveness
(before & after
mapping)
Recent
archive for
most of
needs
Data
sources
Proprietary
systems +
HR commercial
Scientific + low cost
MR
Low cost MR/HR
+ HR commercial
Low cost MR + HR
Low cost MR
+ HR
commercial
HR commercial
+ Charter on
Space
HR
commercial
• $
1.3 billion after 10 years of data sales, the result of more capable satellites, better ground systems & networks
and more users’ education & incentive
• Defense & Security dominates in data sale (66%) while enterprise applications (6 domains for civilian
governments, including research, and the private sector) larger in data volume
• Satellites become more specialized for both science/research & operational purposes (maritime,
oceanography,...)
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
$
in
m
ill
io
n
s
p
er
y
ea
r
New generation of HR
optical & radar systems
OPTICAL
RADAR
Growth in commercial EO data sales
1rst HR commercial
optical systems
•
Operators consolidation in the US and in Europe in 2006 and 2010 and new data producers
•
Strong sale growth in the past 4 years driven by government demand, especially the US
•
Growth supported by a growing supply of HR optical and radar imagery
•
Growing number of companies looking to tap into the commercial data market
Consolidation in
the US
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
2013
2015
2017
2019
All types of missions considered (excepted blacklisted), the number of EOSat should double in the
decade at 300 units
Over 2/3 of future EOSat demand will remain concentrated in the top 6 space powers (USA, Russia,
Europe, China, Japan, and India)
Still about 100 satellites of different capabilities in countries with no space industry, opening export
opportunities for satellite manufacturers and instrument suppliers
Future EOSat demand continues to be dominated by governments that represent 90% of the
expected industry revenues of $50 billion over the decade
EOSat demand dynamics by client
$ in millions at satellite launch date
Military (°)
Commercial (*)
Government (*)
# of satellites
2001-2010
2011-2020
Commercial *
15
40
Government*
85
195
Military°
50
70
Total
150
305
(*) including multiple satellite constellations
(°) excluding blacklisted satellites
Thailand
Chile
UAE
Algeria
Vietnam
Nigeria
Kazakstan
Turkey
Satellite
in-orbit
Theos
SSOT
Dubaisat
Alsat-2a
NigeriaSat-2
NigeriaSat-X
Satellite
TBL
Alsat-2b
VNREDSat-1a
VNREDSat-1b
HRES
MRES
Göktürk-1
Client
GISTDA
Chilean AF
EIAST
ASAL
NRSC
NASRDA
Kazcosmos
Turkish AF
• Emerging EOSat countries have the objective of acquiring satellite technical know-how domestically &
autonomous observation capability
• Satellites of newcomer countries are not equal in terms of performance as operational needs are not the
same: only one submetric to date (Gokturk)
• Imagery of national systems (e.g. India, China, Brazil) provided to other countries commercially or in-kind
Cosmo-SkyMed
Radarsat
TerraSAR/TanDEM-X
Financing
Government funded (Italy)
Government funded (Canada)
PPP with Astrium (Germany)
System
4 X-band satellites
1 C-band satellite
2 X-band satellites (in tandem)
Distributor
e-GEOS (Telespazio + ASI)
MDA Geospatial Service
Astrium Services
GSD
1m
10m & 3m
1m
• HR radar imagery recently available commercially from 2 European-financed systems to
complement pioneer Radarsat: allow applications development and demonstration of operational
systems
Different demand drivers for optical and radar observations
• The commercial provision of value-added services associated to EOsat data has
not experienced the same growth as data sales
• Outsourcing of value-added services by governments remain constrained by
operational conditions
• Service companies are cost sensitive, lower cost data solutions preferred where
available
• Accessibility to commercial data is an issue in case of preferred clients for the
data producers
• But the service sector is stimulated by the economic and policy changes
impacting the value chain
• Emergence of regional one stop geo-information solution providers
• Growth in low-cost/free operational data
• Mechanisms for services development such as GMES
• Service providers with better access to local markets
What’s next for value-added services
Satellite
content
Geo-information
processing &
interpretation sector
Contact:
Rachel Villain
Director Space
villain@euroconsult-ec.com
Adam Keith
Director EO
keith@euroconsult-na.com
Data source:
« Satellite-based Earth observation » report
2011 Edition (4th Edition)
Thank you